Gurpatwant Singh Pannun was sitting in the courtroom when the sentence came down. The man who had, according to American prosecutors, paid to have him killed in New York was standing a few feet away. Nikhil Gupta sentenced to nearly twenty years in a US federal prison, and the target of the plot watched it happen.
Judge Victor Marrero of the Southern District of New York handed Gupta 235 months on Friday, November 20, after a hearing that ran close to 80 minutes, Reuters reported. That is 19 years and seven months, at the lower end of the 235 to 293 month range in the US sentencing guidelines, according to The Times of India. Gupta is 55. He will be an old man when he walks out, if he walks out at all.
The sentence closes the criminal case against the man in the middle of the plot. It does not close the plot itself.
Nikhil Gupta sentenced: the case in five dates
May 2023. Prosecutors say Vikash Yadav, described by the US Department of Justice as an Indian government employee, recruited Gupta to arrange the killing of Pannun, a lawyer with the group Sikhs for Justice who holds American and Canadian citizenship and campaigns for a separate Sikh state.
June 2023. Gupta arranged for $15,000 in cash to be handed to a supposed hitman. The hitman was an undercover American law enforcement officer, court papers show. The agreed price for the killing, prosecutors said, was $100,000. Gupta was arrested in Prague the same month.
November 2023. The US unsealed its indictment, and the case exploded into public view. India denied any official role and set up a high-level committee to examine the American allegations.
February 2026. Gupta pleaded guilty to three charges: murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
November 20, 2026. The sentence. Announcing it, US Attorney Jamie McDonald said the case showed the Justice Department’s determination to prosecute “those involved in attempts to commit violence on American soil or against US citizens,” The Statesman reported.
Why this actually matters
Start with the obvious. A foreign government employee allegedly ordering a killing on American soil, and an Indian national taking the money to arrange it, is the kind of case that poisons a relationship slowly. It has done exactly that since 2023. Every India-US meeting since has carried this file in the background, even when nobody mentions it in public.
The Modi government has consistently denied any official involvement, and nothing in the sentencing changes that position. What changes is the paperwork. A guilty plea followed by a 19-year sentence turns an allegation into a recorded fact in a federal court. Diplomats can argue about what Yadav did or did not do on behalf of whom. They cannot argue that the plot did not exist.
There is a second case running alongside this one, and it matters too. Pannun has filed a separate civil lawsuit in the US against Indian officials, and the Deccan Herald noted that the civil case is distinct from the criminal proceedings against Gupta and Yadav. Yadav himself has not faced trial in the United States. He remains a co-defendant, charged but not in American custody, and that loose end is the part New Delhi will be asked about next.
It has been a week of hard security news in India. Days ago, an encounter in Bulandshahr killed a man linked to Dawood Ibrahim’s network. That was a police operation on home soil, closed in four days. This one took three and a half years, crossed three countries, and ended in a Manhattan courtroom. The contrast says something about how differently the two kinds of cases move, and how much longer the second kind lingers.
What happens now
Gupta serves his sentence in a US federal prison. The defence had pointed out that the plot never came close to succeeding, Pannun is alive, and Gupta has no criminal record in India, The Hindu BusinessLine reported. The judge heard it and still gave him the bottom of the guidelines range, not below it. That is the court saying the crime was the agreement itself, not the outcome.
For India, the practical question is Yadav. Washington will keep pressing for accountability, and New Delhi will keep insisting its enquiry committee process is the answer. Neither side has moved in three years, and a sentence in New York does not move either of them by itself. What it does is remove any doubt about whether the Americans were serious. They were serious enough to put a man away for most of the rest of his working life.
Pannun walked out of that courtroom a free man, the intended victim of a plot that failed. Gupta will not see the outside of a prison for a very long time. That is the whole story, really. Everything else is diplomacy.
